How to Fix Gutters Falling Away From Your House A DIY Guide

You walk outside, look up at your roofline, and notice something isn’t right. That once-straight gutter is now sagging, with a noticeable gap between it and your house. It’s a common problem, but one you can’t afford to ignore. Gutters that are falling away from your house aren't just an eyesore; they're a ticking time bomb for potential water damage to your foundation, siding, and landscaping.

The good news is that you’ve come to the right place. I’m here to walk you through this problem just like I would over the phone. In many cases, fixing a sagging gutter is a manageable DIY project that you can tackle in an afternoon.

This guide will help you diagnose why your gutters are failing, determine if it’s a job you can handle, and provide clear, step-by-step instructions for the most common repairs. Let’s get those gutters back where they belong!

Why Are Your Gutters Pulling Away from the House?

Before we grab the ladder, it’s important to understand what’s causing the problem. When a gutter starts to detach, it’s usually due to one of these four culprits:

1. Clogged Gutters: This is the number one cause. Gutters are designed to carry water, but when they get filled with leaves, twigs, mud, and other debris, they get heavy. A single foot of a 5-inch gutter can hold about 1.2 gallons of water, weighing nearly 10 pounds. Now imagine 20 feet of gutter filled with wet, decomposing leaves—that’s hundreds of pounds of stress pulling on the fasteners.
2. Failed or Spaced-Out Fasteners: The brackets, hangers, or screws that hold your gutters in place can fail over time. They might corrode, work their way loose due to thermal expansion and contraction, or they may have been installed too far apart in the first place (they should typically be no more than 2-3 feet apart).
3. Rotten Fascia Board: This is a more serious issue. The fascia is the long, straight board that runs along the lower edge of your roof, and it’s what your gutters are mounted to. If water has been overflowing from clogged gutters and seeping behind them, the wooden fascia can rot. Rotten wood is soft and spongy, and it simply can’t hold the screws and fasteners securely.
4. Improper Pitch: Gutters need a slight, almost unnoticeable slope toward the downspout to drain effectively. If the pitch is incorrect or has shifted over time, water can pool in sections, adding weight and strain.

Now that we know what we might be up against, let's gather our tools and get ready for a closer look.

Tools and Safety Gear You'll Need

Safety is paramount when you’re working on a ladder. Make sure your ladder is on stable, level ground and always maintain three points of contact.

Safety First:

• Sturdy Extension Ladder: Ensure it's tall enough to comfortably reach the gutters.
• Ladder Stabilizer (Recommended): This accessory helps prevent the ladder from sliding and keeps it from damaging your gutters.
• Work Gloves: To protect your hands from sharp edges and grimy debris.
• Safety Glasses: To shield your eyes from falling debris.

Tools & Materials:

• Drill with Driver Bits: For tightening or installing new fasteners.
• Gutter Scoop or Trowel: For clearing out clogs.
• Garden Hose with a Spray Nozzle: For flushing the gutters after cleaning.
• Bucket or Trash Bag: To collect the debris you remove.
• New Gutter Hangers and Screws: If you need to replace old ones. We recommend 7-inch exterior-grade screws for a strong hold.

Your Step-by-Step Guide to Fixing Sagging Gutters

We'll approach this like a detective, starting with a thorough inspection to find the root cause.

Step 1: Perform a Safe Inspection

Position your ladder safely on level ground near the sagging section. Put on your gloves and safety glasses before you climb. Ascend until your eyes are about level with the bottom of the gutter so you can get a clear view of the situation.

Here's what you're looking for:

• Check the Fascia Board: Look at the wood directly behind the gutter. Do you see peeling paint, dark stains, or soft, crumbling spots? Try carefully poking it with a screwdriver (if you can reach safely). If it's soft and gives way easily, you're dealing with wood rot.
• Inspect the Fasteners: Look at the hangers or brackets holding the gutter. Are they bent? Are the screws backing out? Are any missing entirely?
• Look for Clogs: Peer inside the gutter. Is it packed with leaves, pine needles, or sludge? Is there standing water? This weight is a likely contributor to the problem.
• Check the Pitch: Eyeball the length of the gutter run. Does it appear to slope gently toward the downspout? Any obvious dips or low spots are a red flag.

Step 2: Diagnose the Problem and Find Your Solution

Based on your inspection, you can now identify the cause and the correct course of action.

• If you found rotten fascia board... Diagnosis: This is the most serious issue. The structural wood that holds the gutter is compromised. Solution: Stop and call a professional. The gutter needs to be removed, the rotten fascia board must be replaced by a carpenter, and then the gutter can be reinstalled. This is typically not a simple DIY job.

• If you found heavy clogs... Diagnosis: The sheer weight of debris is likely pulling the gutter down. Solution: The first and easiest step is a thorough cleaning. Jump down to our guide on How to Clean Your Gutters. Often, simply removing the weight is enough to let the gutter return to its proper position.

• If you found loose or broken fasteners... Diagnosis: The hangers are no longer securing the gutter to the fascia. Solution: This is a very common and fixable DIY problem. You'll need to tighten or replace the fasteners. Proceed to our guide on How to Replace Gutter Fasteners.

• If the pitch seems wrong or the gutter is bent... Diagnosis: The system isn't draining correctly due to improper installation or damage. Solution: Adjusting gutter pitch can be tricky to get right. If you’ve cleaned the gutters and secured the fasteners but it still sags or holds water, it’s best to call a gutter contractor. They have the tools and experience to properly align the entire system.

How to Fix the Most Common Gutter Issues

If your diagnosis points to clogged gutters or loose fasteners, you're in luck. Here’s how to tackle those repairs yourself.

Guide 1: Clean the Gutters to Reduce Weight

1. Position Your Ladder: Start at the end of the gutter nearest a downspout.
2. Scoop Out Debris: Using your gutter scoop or trowel, pull all the leaves, mud, and gunk out of the gutter. It’s helpful to have a bucket or a trash bag hanging from your ladder to drop the debris into.
3. Work in Sections: Clear a section of the gutter you can safely reach, then carefully move the ladder down and repeat the process until the entire length is clear.
4. Flush with Water: Once all the large debris is gone, use your garden hose to spray a stream of water through the gutter toward the downspout. This will flush out any remaining grime and, just as importantly, show you if the water is flowing freely.
5. Assess the Result: After cleaning, is the gutter still sagging? If it has pulled back into place, the clog was your problem! If it's still pulling away, the fasteners have likely been permanently loosened and you'll need to proceed to the next guide.

Guide 2: Replace or Tighten Gutter Fasteners

1. Position and Secure the Ladder: Place your ladder near the start of the loose section.
2. Remove Old, Loose Fasteners: If you have old spikes that have pulled out, use the back of a hammer to remove them. If you have hangers with screws, use your drill in reverse to back them out.
3. Install New Hangers: Modern gutter hangers are far superior to old spikes. They clip onto the inside lip of the gutter and have a hole for a long screw. Hold the new hanger in place.
4. Drive the Screw: Drive a new 7-inch exterior screw through the hanger, through the back of the gutter, and deep into the fascia board and underlying rafter tail. You’ll feel it bite into the solid wood. Don’t overtighten, just make it snug.
5. Space Them Correctly: Continue adding new hangers every 24 inches along the entire loose section of the gutter. If you see existing fasteners that are just a little loose, simply tighten them with your drill.
6. Check Your Work: The gutter should now be sitting flush and secure against the fascia board. Sight down its length to make sure it still has a gentle slope toward the downspout.

When to Call a Gutter Professional

DIY is rewarding, but it’s crucial to know your limits, especially when working at heights. It's time to call a professional roofer or gutter contractor if:

• You discover rotten fascia boards.
• The gutters are physically bent or damaged.
• After your repairs, the gutter still sags or holds water, indicating a pitch problem.
• You are uncomfortable or feel unsafe working on a ladder.

According to HomeAdvisor, a professional gutter repair can cost anywhere from $180 to $560, depending on the extent of the damage. While a DIY fix is cheaper, professional help is a worthwhile investment for complex issues or for your own safety.

Final Thoughts

Fixing a gutter that's falling away from your house is a critical task for protecting your home’s value and integrity. By carefully inspecting the problem, you can determine whether it's a simple matter of cleaning out debris and tightening a few screws or a more complex issue requiring professional help.

For more expert guidance on home maintenance projects big and small, download the Casa app. It's your go-to resource for step-by-step DIY guides, and it can connect you with trusted, vetted professionals in your area when you need a helping hand. Take control of your home maintenance with Casa today